7.88 avg 13 episodes 8.1 → 8.8 44 min avg
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pilot | 8.1 | 2,319 |
| 2 | Blood Moon | 7.5 | 1,485 |
| 3 | For the Triumph of Evil | 7.6 | 1,369 |
| 4 | The Lesser Key of Solomon | 7.7 | 1,248 |
| 5 | John Doe | 7.6 | 1,173 |
| 6 | The Sin Eater | 7.8 | 1,175 |
| 7 | The Midnight Ride | 8.0 | 1,058 |
| 8 | Necromancer | 8.1 | 1,087 |
| 9 | Sanctuary | 7.8 | 1,022 |
| 10 | The Golem | 7.7 | 973 |
| 11 | The Vessel | 7.8 | 914 |
| 12 | The Indispensable Man | 7.9 | 909 |
| 13 | Bad Blood | 8.8 | 1,213 |
7.66 avg 18 episodes 8.0 → 8.7 44 min avg
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | This Is War | 8.0 | 950 |
| 2 | The Kindred | 7.7 | 788 |
| 3 | Root of All Evil | 7.6 | 745 |
| 4 | Go Where I Send Thee... | 7.5 | 726 |
| 5 | The Weeping Lady | 7.7 | 750 |
| 6 | And the Abyss Gazes Back | 7.6 | 692 |
| 7 | Deliverance | 7.5 | 687 |
| 8 | Heartless | 7.5 | 682 |
| 9 | Mama | 7.6 | 695 |
| 10 | Magnum Opus | 7.7 | 656 |
| 11 | The Akeda | 8.1 | 719 |
| 12 | Paradise Lost | 7.3 | 659 |
| 13 | Pittura Infamante | 7.4 | 639 |
| 14 | Kali Yuga | 7.4 | 633 |
| 15 | Spellcaster | 7.4 | 621 |
| 16 | What Lies Beneath | 7.3 | 639 |
| 17 | Awakening | 7.9 | 689 |
| 18 | Tempus Fugit | 8.7 | 866 |
7.49 avg 18 episodes 7.7 → 7.0 44 min avg
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | I, Witness | 7.7 | 654 |
| 2 | Whispers in the Dark | 7.3 | 541 |
| 3 | Blood and Fear | 7.4 | 522 |
| 4 | The Sisters Mills | 7.7 | 518 |
| 5 | Dead Men Tell No Tales | 7.5 | 561 |
| 6 | This Red Lady from Caribee | 7.3 | 472 |
| 7 | The Art of War | 7.5 | 485 |
| 8 | Novus Ordo Seclorum | 7.7 | 490 |
| 9 | One Life | 7.5 | 445 |
| 10 | Incident at Stone Manor | 7.8 | 452 |
| 11 | Kindred Spirits | 7.3 | 434 |
| 12 | Sins of the Father | 7.4 | 419 |
| 13 | Dark Mirror | 7.3 | 418 |
| 14 | Into the Wild | 7.4 | 403 |
| 15 | Incommunicado | 7.7 | 418 |
| 16 | Dawn's Early Light | 7.6 | 413 |
| 17 | Delaware | 7.7 | 422 |
| 18 | Ragnarok | 7.0 | 567 |
7.40 avg 13 episodes 7.3 → 7.5 43 min avg
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Columbia | 7.3 | 488 |
| 2 | In Plain Sight | 7.6 | 420 |
| 3 | Heads of State | 7.6 | 389 |
| 4 | The People v. Ichabod Crane | 7.5 | 394 |
| 5 | Blood from a Stone | 7.4 | 369 |
| 6 | Homecoming | 7.5 | 363 |
| 7 | Loco Parentis | 7.2 | 361 |
| 8 | Sick Burn | 7.1 | 359 |
| 9 | Child's Play | 7.0 | 340 |
| 10 | Insatiable | 7.1 | 335 |
| 11 | The Way of the Gun | 7.6 | 346 |
| 12 | Tomorrow | 7.8 | 341 |
| 13 | Freedom | 7.5 | 380 |